GovKM
Government

GAO 27-108813: Before Commerce Consolidates Office Space, Can It Verify Who Uses It?

GAO found that most Commerce office locations it reviewed fell below the federal utilization benchmark and that one bureau overstated use by reporting assigned staff in place of daily attendance. GovKM proposes linking occupancy measurements, capacity records, and consolidation decisions so staff and AI can verify the evidence.
Two facilities analysts review a floor plan beside rows of empty office workstations.
Expand image

What GAO found

About 59 percent of the Department of Commerce’s 351 office locations fell below the 60 percent utilization benchmark during the period GAO examined, January 12 through March 6, 2026. GAO also found that Commerce spent more than $220 million in fiscal year 2025 on locations it identified as underutilized. That spending measures the cost of those locations. Potential savings would depend on which spaces Commerce could consolidate or exit and the costs of doing so. GAO-27-108813

Commerce used badge swipes at its largest offices and reported using daily check-in surveys at most locations. Some bureaus applied the survey method differently. One reported the number of employees assigned to an office in place of the number physically present each day, overstating utilization. GAO also identified 10 metropolitan areas where multiple Commerce bureaus occupied underused locations. It recommended aligning bureau survey procedures with GSA guidance and incorporating a department-wide consolidation plan into Commerce’s real property capital plan. Commerce concurred with both recommendations. GAO findings and recommendations

The Organizational Information Continuity challenge

Can the next analyst tell what the number measured? A utilization percentage depends on what counted as attendance, which days were observed, and how capacity was defined. When a bureau changes survey tools or a space is reconfigured, a new figure may use a different method or capacity baseline. If the reporting record carries only the percentage, the next analyst may interpret a change in measurement as a change in office use. An AI assistant could rank two sites as if their numbers were comparable and point facilities staff toward the wrong location for review.

Can leadership reconstruct why a site was selected? An occupancy report can flag a location for review. Deciding whether to consolidate requires further evidence, including the available receiving space, mission needs, lease terms, and the costs of a move. If the capital plan preserves only the selected site and a savings estimate, later reviewers may be unable to determine which alternatives and assumptions supported the decision. An AI assistant could repeat an earlier recommendation as current after a lease deadline or capacity estimate changes. These are prospective reporting and decision-support risks identified by GovKM.

GovKM’s proposed approach

  1. Capture what each site actually measured. Assign a reporting owner to each site. Use the applicable GSA identifier, the reporting dates, daily physical occupancy totals, and the associated office usable square footage. Retain the collection method, the date it took effect, and the capacity input used to calculate utilization. A roster can help administer a daily survey. Attendance needs evidence of physical presence. Record missing observations and corrections so a blank entry cannot silently become a zero. OMB Memorandum M-25-25 · GSA reporting guidelines · GSA daily check-in survey playbook

2. Review the evidence before comparing sites. Have facilities and real property staff verify that the counts refer to the same space and period as the capacity data. Require a reviewer to resolve or flag discrepancies such as a survey value copied from a roster or a capacity figure that predates a floor closure. Preserve the submitted report and any approved revision together. The USE IT Act directs OMB, in consultation with GSA, to ensure at least 60 percent average utilization over each one-year period in covered space, subject to the statutory provisions. GAO’s early-2026 observation window provides evidence for planning. Keep the observation period visible wherever the figure is used. Public Law 118-272, section 2302

3. Link each decision to the evidence available when officials made it. For each metropolitan area under review, preserve the occupancy and capacity figures considered, candidate receiving locations, mission constraints, lease milestones, estimated costs, alternatives, and approval record. Use the approved capital plan to track the action owner and schedule. Federal agency heads have a general duty to document and preserve records of agency functions, decisions, procedures, and essential transactions. The proposed decision record is GovKM’s way of supporting that duty. 44 U.S.C. § 3101

OrgAI’s proposed role is to help authorized staff trace a reported utilization figure or consolidation recommendation to its supporting records and identify when those records have changed. That capability is in development. Facilities and real property officials retain responsibility for validating the data and approving decisions.

Verify that the decision can be reconstructed

Ask a reviewer who did not prepare the report to reproduce one site’s utilization figure from the daily counts and the applicable capacity record. Then ask them to trace one consolidation proposal to the options, assumptions, and approval that supported it. Repeat the exercise after a staff handoff or reporting-system change.

Test AI-assisted reporting with an assigned headcount and a physical attendance count for the same office, plus an older capacity figure and its approved replacement. The answer should identify which inputs support the reported period and flag comparisons the evidence cannot support.

A hospital network, university, or company can use the same approach when comparing sites or changing its footprint. Each organization should apply its own reporting and property rules. The transferable practice is to keep the measurement and its basis connected to the decision that relied on it.

Contact GovKM to discuss an Organizational Information Continuity assessment for facilities reporting, consolidation decisions, or governed AI analysis.

RELATED FRAMEWORK DOMAINS

Explore the Connected Framework

Continue through the framework domains connected to this article.

No items found.
RELATED KNOWLEDGE

Continue Exploring

Explore related research, framework domains, and continuity concepts.
CONTINUE WITH THE FRAMEWORK

Explore the continuity relationships that support trustworthy organizational intelligence.

Continue through the GovKM Framework to examine the doctrine, knowledge, and implementation guidance behind Organizational Continuity.